top of page
Search

Mat or Reformer: Which Is Better for Beginners?

Nov 6
3 min read

It’s one of the questions new clients ask me most: “Should I start with mat Pilates or go straight to the reformer?”. I'm biased towards mat, because I love it! I've done Reformer Pilates, but I find working with my own body weight is more satisfying (but that's just my personal preference).


The honest answer is that neither is better for everyone. The best one for you is the one that fits your body, your goals, your budget, and the kind of support you need right now. Here’s how to decide.


What’s the difference?

Mat Pilates is done on the floor using your own body weight for resistance. Sometimes small props such as a band, ball, or magic circle are added.

Reformer Pilates uses a spring-loaded machine with a sliding carriage, straps, and a footbar. The springs provide resistance, and they can also give support, depending on how the machine is set up.

Both come from the same method, and both build strength, control, posture, and body awareness.


The case for starting with mat

  • It’s accessible. You only need a mat and some space, so you can start in a class, at home, or even on holiday.

  • It’s usually cheaper. There’s no equipment to buy, and classes are often less expensive than reformer sessions.

  • It teaches the fundamentals. With nothing but your own body to work with, you learn control, alignment, breathing, and how to find your deep core muscles. These are the foundations of every Pilates exercise.

  • It’s easy to fit into your week. Short sessions at home between classes help you build a regular habit.

The catch: mat work can feel harder than it looks. With no springs to guide or support you, there’s more reliance on your own strength and body awareness. Without a teacher, it’s also easy to practise the movements slightly wrong without noticing.


The case for starting with reformer

  • It can support your body. The springs can assist a movement as well as challenge it, which can make some exercises easier to feel and perform correctly.

  • It offers variety and progression. Springs can be adjusted, so the same exercise can be made gentler or harder.

  • It gives clear feedback. Many people find it easier to feel what the right muscles should be doing when the machine gives resistance to work against.

  • It’s often taught in a studio with close guidance, especially in small groups or private sessions.

The catch: it costs more, it needs a studio (or the space and budget for your own machine), and the setup can feel confusing in your first few sessions, with straps, springs, and settings to learn.


So which should you choose?

Choose mat if:

  • You’re on a tighter budget or want to practise at home

  • You want to learn the principles and basics first

  • You’re happy with a simple, flexible routine

Choose reformer if:

  • You’d like more support and feedback while you learn

  • You’re returning from injury and have medical clearance with a teacher who can adapt the work

  • You prefer studio sessions with close guidance

Or do both. Many people do exactly that, using mat classes to build habit and reformer sessions for variety and added resistance. They complement each other well.


What about weight loss?

If weight loss is your main goal, you may have heard that reformer burns more. Some studies suggest it burns slightly more calories per minute than mat, but the gap is modest, and consistency matters far more than the equipment. The best choice is the one you’ll keep turning up for.


What matters more than mat or reformer

Whichever you start with, these things matter more than the equipment:

  1. A qualified, experienced teacher. Ask about their training. It should be with a reputable pilates school. At Pilatestar, all our teachers were taught by Body Control Pilates Association - It operates as Europe's largest professional Pilates organisation and independent training body, similar level shcools include Pilates Foundation, APPI, BASI, Stott.

  2. Small groups or private sessions at first, so you get feedback.

  3. Telling your teacher about any injuries, conditions, or recent surgery before you begin.

  4. Learning the basics well, rather than rushing to look advanced.

  5. Turning up regularly. Consistency beats intensity.


The bottom line

If you’re unsure, mat Pilates is a great place to start. It’s accessible, affordable, and teaches the foundations. But if a reformer class appeals to you and there is a studio is nearby, that’s a perfectly good place to begin too - not something that Pilatestar does.


Not sure which suits you? Get in touch. We can talk through your goals and find the right starting point for you. We'll be honest!

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page